Course Description
This panel focuses on the ongoing increase in AI-related disclosure litigation and enforcement, known as “AI-washing,” which allege that companies compete for business under AI-related marketing and promotion without building the underlying technological infrastructure and process implied in their public facing materials. This session examines the defense side of AI-related securities fraud litigation, with a focus on AI-washing class actions, emerging pleading theories, the tools available to defeat claims at the motion-to-dismiss stage, and the current SEC and DOJ enforcement posture. The session will provide defense counsel with a practical framework for auditing AI-related disclosures, developing dismissal arguments, and advising clients on enforcement response and cooperation strategy.
Principles
- Introductions / Program Framing and Defense Objectives.
- The session opens by defining AI-washing in the securities litigation context and identifying the defense questions that recur across class actions, SEC inquiries, and parallel enforcement risk.
- Current Landscape of AI-Related Securities Claims.
- This section details the principal categories of AI-related allegations, including overstated capabilities, exaggerated automation, misleading revenue narratives, deficient risk disclosures, and claims following short-seller reports or stock drops.
- Actionability: Puffery, Opinion, Falsity, and Safe Harbor.
- This section reviews how courts distinguish aspirational AI statements, generalized innovation claims, and forward-looking projections from concrete, verifiable representations that may support liability.
- Scienter: Why AI-Washing Complaints Often Fail.
- This section addresses the PSLRA’s particularity requirements, the limits of alleging knowledge from corporate position alone, and defense arguments against hindsight pleading, confidential-witness allegations, and generalized access-to-information theories.
- Hidden Human Involvement.
- The section analyzes how liability theories arise when companies market AI-driven systems while relying materially on human review, intervention, or manual workarounds.
- Enforcement Overlay: SEC, DOJ, and Cooperation Strategy.
- This section considers how civil AI-washing exposure may trigger regulatory inquiries, what factors can heighten criminal/civil risk, and how defense counsel should counsel clients on preservation, internal investigations, remediation, and cooperation.
- Short-Seller Reports, Loss Causation, and Takeaways.
- The session concludes with a discussion of short-seller reports as both litigation catalysts and defense opportunities, followed by practical takeaways for advising issuers and executives.
Syllabus
- AI-Washing Litigation Landscape
- Puffery, Opinion, and Safe-Harbor Defenses
- Scienter in AI-Related Securities Claims
- Undisclosed Human Involvement and Operational Reality
- Enforcement Trends
- Short-Seller Reports and Loss Causation